🎉 Welcome to AssetWisp! 🔥 50% 0ff Use code

Insider Trading Activity Screener: Follow the Smart Money

Insider Trading Activity Screener: Follow the Smart Money — AssetWisp Blog

Key Takeaways

  • Open-market purchases, reported with transaction code P on Form 4, are the only insider trade type that reliably signals conviction; grants, option exercises, and tax withholding are compensation mechanics.
  • Cluster buying, meaning two or more independent insiders making code P purchases in the same stock within roughly 30 days, is the strongest pattern a screener can surface.
  • Five stacked filters (trade type, size relative to pay, insider count, recency, and price context) turn hundreds of daily Form 4 filings into a shortlist you can actually review.
  • Research by Cohen, Malloy and Pomorski found that opportunistic insider trades carry the predictive information, while routine, calendar-driven trades carry essentially none.
  • SEC EDGAR posts Form 4 filings as they are submitted but offers no signal filtering, so verify every alert there, then check fundamentals and size positions conservatively before acting.

To follow the smart money through insider trading activity, use a screener that separates open-market insider purchases from routine option exercises, grants, and pre-scheduled 10b5-1 sales, then filter for cluster buying by several insiders within weeks of each other. This guide shows which Form 4 transaction codes signal real conviction, which to ignore, how to stack five filters into a repeatable screen, and how free and paid tools compare on lag and coverage.

What Counts as a Genuine Smart-Money Signal in Insider Filings?

Insider trading activity, in the legal and reportable sense, is when a company's officers, directors, or holders of more than 10% of a class of its securities buy or sell company stock and report it to the SEC. It is legal and public. The illegal kind, trading on material nonpublic information, is a different thing entirely.

Who Counts as an Insider Under SEC Rules

Under Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act, these insiders must report changes in their holdings on Form 4, generally within two business days of the transaction. The SEC's investor bulletin on insider transactions and Forms 3, 4, and 5 explains who files and lists the common transaction codes. Each filing shows the trade date, price, share count, and code, which is the raw material every insider screener works from.

Why Buying Signals More Than Selling

An open-market purchase means the insider chose to spend personal cash at the current market price. There are few reasons to do that other than believing the shares are worth more. Sales happen for many reasons that have nothing to do with the outlook: diversification, taxes, a house purchase, or a pre-scheduled trading plan. That asymmetry is why serious smart-money followers weight buys heavily and treat most sales as noise. For a broader framework on reading any signal without over-trusting it, see how to use AI stock signals without blindly following them.

Which Insider Trade Types Should You Follow and Which Should You Ignore?

Every Form 4 transaction carries a code, and that code tells you whether the trade says anything about conviction. Treat the codes as tiers, not equals.

Open-Market Buys: The Conviction Trade

Code P is a purchase on an exchange or from another person. It is the closest a filing comes to showing skin in the game, and it is the tier worth building a watchlist around. A single buy is a data point; several insiders buying the same stock within weeks is the pattern to investigate.

Grants, Exercises, and Withholding: Compensation, Not Conviction

Code A is a grant or award from the company. Code M is the exercise or conversion of an option or other derivative received from the company. Code F is shares withheld or delivered to pay an exercise price or tax bill, usually at vesting. Code G is a gift. These transactions happen because a pay package or a vesting date made them happen, not because the insider made a fresh bet. Filter them out or you will drown in filings that carry no signal.

10b5-1 Plan Sales: Scheduled in Advance

Code S covers any sale on an exchange or to another person. Whether that sale was made under a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan is not a separate code; since the SEC's 2022 amendments, insiders must tick a checkbox on Form 4 indicating a trade was intended to satisfy Rule 10b5-1. Plan sales were scheduled months earlier, often for tax or diversification reasons, so they say little about the insider's current view.

Trade typeHow it shows on Form 4Signal strengthFollow or ignore
Open-market purchaseCode PHighFollow
Cluster of insider purchasesSeveral code P filings, different insidersHighestFollow closely
Discretionary saleCode S, 10b5-1 box uncheckedLow to moderateNote, do not act alone
Plan saleCode S, 10b5-1 box checkedLowIgnore
Grant or awardCode ANoneIgnore
Option exercise or tax withholdingCode M or FNoneIgnore
GiftCode GNoneIgnore

How Do Free Insider Screeners Compare to Paid Platforms on Lag and Coverage?

What Free Tools Give You, and What They Don't

The primary free source is the SEC itself. EDGAR full-text search lets you filter by form type and company, and Form 4 filings appear as soon as they are accepted. The catch is that you get raw filings. There is no ranking by trade type, no detection of multiple insiders buying the same stock, and no congressional trades at all, since those come from separate STOCK Act disclosure systems run by the House and Senate.

Where General Finance Apps Fit

Mainstream apps such as Yahoo Finance cover news, charts, and portfolios well and show insider transactions on a quote page, but insider screening is not their focus. They work as a companion for checking a ticker after you have spotted a filing elsewhere. Dedicated paid insider screeners add clustering, alerting, and deeper filters, usually for a monthly fee.

Where AssetWisp Fits, Honestly

AssetWisp's insider feed is built from public Form 4 filings and focuses on open-market purchases and sales, so grants, exercises, withholding, and gifts stay out of the way. The Insiders tab in the app's Alerts section lets you switch between buys, sells, and $1M+ trades or search a single ticker, and each stock's detail screen shows its insider trades next to Congress trades, so the filing and the context sit in one place. Pro subscribers can also turn on Insider Buys notifications for large open-market purchases.

Where it falls short: AssetWisp does not flag the 10b5-1 checkbox, size a buy against the insider's salary, or detect clusters automatically, and dedicated paid trackers offer deeper filter options. Treat it as a shortlist and context layer, and cross-check the raw filing before acting. The portfolio dashboard walkthrough shows how holdings and signals are organized.

What Filters Reveal High-Conviction Cluster Buying Versus Routine Activity?

This is where most screeners quietly fail you. They show every Form 4 as an equal row in a table, so a routine option exercise sits next to a CEO spending six figures of after-tax cash on the open market. A serious workflow applies five filters in order, because each one decides whether the next even matters. The thresholds below are working heuristics, not rules from any regulator.

Filters 1-3: Trade Type, Size, and Insider Count

Trade type. Keep code P purchases. Drop A, M, F, and G, and set aside code S sales unless the 10b5-1 box is unchecked and the sale is unusually large.

Size relative to the insider. A purchase worth a meaningful share of the insider's annual pay, or a meaningful increase in their existing stake, is one they had to think about. A $5,000 buy by an executive with a seven-figure package is not. Compensation figures are in the company's proxy statement.

Insider count. One bullish director is an opinion; several is a pattern. For this screen, define a cluster as two or more independent insiders making code P purchases in the same stock within about 30 days, and treat three or more as the stronger version. If a screener cannot sort by these three fields, it is a filing reader, not a smart-money tool.

Filters 4-5: Recency and Price Context

Recency. Measure the 30-day window by transaction date, not filing date. Most Form 4s land within two business days, but late filings happen, so always compare both dates. A buy that is weeks old by the time you see it has less edge left.

Price context. A purchase near a 52-week low after a sharp drop reads differently from one near the high. Buying into weakness can signal that insiders think the market overreacted, but check whether the drop came with news you already know about. AssetWisp's approach to surfacing market-moving news helps here. Five filters, applied in order, turn hundreds of filings into a shortlist you can actually review.

What Red Flags Mean an Insider Trade Is Not a Signal?

Most Form 4s are noise, and a few patterns tell you to skip them. Sales with the 10b5-1 box checked were scheduled in advance. Option exercises and shares withheld for taxes are mechanical. Grants to newly appointed directors arrive with the appointment, not by choice. A single small open-market buy, say under $50,000 at a large company, rarely moves the needle on its own.

Timing is the subtler red flag. Many insiders trade in the same open window after every earnings report, year after year. Research on these patterns, covered below, found that such routine, calendar-driven trades carry essentially no predictive value, so a buy that matches an insider's usual annual rhythm deserves less weight than one that breaks it. For how sector-level flows change these reads, see AssetWisp's sector rotation analysis.

How Do You Turn an Insider Buy Alert Into a Trade Decision?

Verify the Filing Yourself

Every alert should start at the source. Pull the Form 4 on EDGAR and confirm the code is P, the price and share count make sense against that day's trading range, and the 10b5-1 box is unchecked. Check the transaction date against the alert date.

Separate Opportunistic From Routine Trades

The most useful academic lens here is Cohen, Malloy and Pomorski's "Decoding Inside Information". They classified insiders who trade in the same calendar month year after year as routine, and everyone else as opportunistic. Opportunistic trades contained essentially all the predictive power: a portfolio built on them earned value-weighted abnormal returns of about 82 basis points per month in their sample, while routine traders' abnormal returns were roughly zero. So check the insider's filing history. A first purchase in years, or one that breaks a seasonal pattern, carries more information than another trade in a familiar rhythm.

Size the Trade and Set Levels

Treat the cluster as a thesis, not a tip. A common risk-management rule of thumb is to keep any single idea to a small slice of the portfolio, often 1%-2%, and to set a stop below a recent range low so the thesis is falsifiable. The math behind that trade-off is covered in swing trade risk-reward done for you. None of this is investment advice; it is a process for deciding whether a filing deserves your money at all.

How Should Insider Activity Be Combined With Fundamentals?

Insider buying alone is a weak standalone signal. Executives buy for many reasons, including confidence in a roadmap you cannot see, so treat a cluster buy as a prompt to investigate, not a green light. Before acting, check three things.

  • Valuation. A CEO buying a stock at a high multiple is a different signal than the same buy after a 40% drawdown.
  • Earnings trend. Revenue and margin direction over the last few quarters tells you whether insiders are catching a recovery or averaging into a decline.
  • A second opinion. An AI score, like the AssetWisp AI Overall Investment Score, checks the setup against technical, fundamental, and sentiment data so you are not relying on one filing.

If insider buying, improving fundamentals, and the score all point the same way, you have a thesis worth researching further rather than a headline trade. For a step-by-step verification checklist, see how to verify stocks with the most insider buying, and for small caps specifically, penny stocks with high insider buying.

Screen Insider Buys With AssetWisp

AssetWisp filters EDGAR insider filings down to open-market purchases and large sales, shows them next to Congress trades and the AI Overall Investment Score, and can notify you when a large insider buy lands. Explore the full feature set or compare plans on the pricing page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. Members of Congress must disclose stock trades under the STOCK Act through periodic transaction reports, which are public records. Trackers aggregate those filings, so using one is legal. Because the law allows up to 45 days to report a trade, congressional data can lag the actual trade date by weeks.

How long after a Form 4 is filed can I see the trade?

Insiders generally must file Form 4 within two business days of the transaction, and it appears on SEC EDGAR once accepted. Screeners pulling from EDGAR add their own processing lag, from minutes to a day. Late filings do occur, so always check the transaction date as well as the filing date.

Do insider buys actually predict stock returns?

Selectively. Cohen, Malloy and Pomorski found that opportunistic insider trades, those that break an insider's usual calendar pattern, carried essentially all the predictive power, while routine trades showed roughly zero abnormal returns. Single small buys are weak evidence; clusters of independent insiders making sizable open-market purchases are the pattern worth investigating.

What is the difference between a congress trading app and an insider screener?

They read different filings. An insider screener processes Form 4s filed with the SEC by officers, directors, and 10% holders. A congress trading app processes STOCK Act periodic transaction reports filed by members of Congress on House and Senate systems. Some apps, including AssetWisp, show both on the same stock screen.

Can I get alerts when a CEO buys stock?

Yes. EDGAR itself shows filings as they post but does not filter for signal. Paid trackers and some apps push notifications on new filings with varying lag and filtering. AssetWisp Pro subscribers can enable Insider Buys notifications, which cover large open-market purchases and skip option exercises, grants, and withholding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. Members of Congress must disclose stock trades under the STOCK Act through periodic transaction reports, which are public records. Trackers aggregate those filings, so using one is legal. Because the law allows up to 45 days to report a trade, congressional data can lag the actual trade date by weeks.

Insiders generally must file Form 4 within two business days of the transaction, and it appears on SEC EDGAR once accepted. Screeners pulling from EDGAR add their own processing lag, from minutes to a day. Late filings do occur, so always check the transaction date as well as the filing date.

Selectively. Cohen, Malloy and Pomorski found that opportunistic insider trades, those that break an insider's usual calendar pattern, carried essentially all the predictive power, while routine trades showed roughly zero abnormal returns. Single small buys are weak evidence; clusters of independent insiders making sizable open-market purchases are the pattern worth investigating.

They read different filings. An insider screener processes Form 4s filed with the SEC by officers, directors, and 10% holders. A congress trading app processes STOCK Act periodic transaction reports filed by members of Congress on House and Senate systems. Some apps, including AssetWisp, show both on the same stock screen.

Yes. EDGAR itself shows filings as they post but does not filter for signal. Paid trackers and some apps push notifications on new filings with varying lag and filtering. AssetWisp Pro subscribers can enable Insider Buys notifications, which cover large open-market purchases and skip option exercises, grants, and withholding.

Written by AssetWisp Team

Finance Writer at AssetWisp

The all-in-one platform for tracking and optimizing your investment portfolio across multiple asset classes.

Instagram
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Resources
Contact Us
414 W. Parkway St,
Denton, TX 76201
Download app
Google Play BackgroundGet it on

AssetWisp's AI provides market analysis and predictions based on historical data and existing market patterns for informational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Our predictions do not guarantee future results and cannot substitute professional investment counsel. All investments involve risk of loss. Past performance does not indicate future outcomes. Please consult qualified financial advisors before making investment decisions. See our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, and Risk Disclosure for complete details.

Copyright ©2025 AssetWisp. All rights reserved